Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Walt French's avatar

The attack on a fundamental principle of America—that we should be free to practice religion (or not), the principle that brought the original English settlers here, is bad enough

But if *I* were an immigrant, instead of a descendant of those Euro-Americans, I’d be doubly insulted by the claim that immigrants worship some secular liberalism

According to Pew, an approximately equal percentage of immigrants profess Christianity as we “Heritage” Americans, but they’re much more likely to attend services. Approximately ½ the share of immigrants profess no religious connection but what has Vance and the rest of the “Blood and Soil” crowd so upset is that a larger share of immigrants observe Biddhism, Hinduism and Gawd Forbid, Islam

So it seems perfectly clear: the justification for hating on immigrants is not for their failure to be religious, nor their failure to be Catholic or other Christians, but simply hatred of people who thought their sincere beliefs had a place in a confident, thriving America

Alexandar Mihailovic's avatar

Rather amusing that Pecknold, who sees his Catholic identity as an absolute non-negotiable, has no problem in breaking bread with evangelical Protestants who are outspoken in regarding his faith as idolatry at best, and Satanism at worst. For the them, the “whore of Babylon’ in the Book of Revelation—their favorite book of the New Testament—is unequivocally the Catholic Church. No less revealing is the fact that he is unperturbed by cheerleading the cruel expulsion of Haitian immigrants, almost all of whom are his co-religionists. Does this man have no knowledge of the mouth-frothing hatred directed at Catholic immigrants from the middle of the nineteenth century to at least the beginning of WW2? Even the German Catholics from Bavaria—from whom Pecknold is presumably descended, judging from his name—were considered ‘unassimilable’ at the end of the 19th century. Why is his understanding of this history so sketchy?

16 more comments...

Ready for more?