19 Comments
User's avatar
AMITABH SINGH's avatar

This is so well-written and eye opening for someone like me who was completely ignorant of the ethos liberal temperance. I guess the big question is whether liberal temperance will yield a politically palatable outcome and what cost. Otherwise it is an exercise in acadamic “skulduggery”?

Shikha Dalmia's avatar

Not sure what you mean by "politically palatable outcome." If it means "my policy preferences" then obviously a liberal democratic polity where these preferences are contested at every level can't guarantee such an outcome. If it means holding political actors like the former president and his mob accountable to the rule of law then of course liberal temperance does not preclude that. But it does mean that we do so not in the spirit of revenge but accountability.

Jerry's avatar

Thanks for proving my perfectly.

SV's avatar

Classical Liberals were against war and big government. Something has changed, and it's not me. The far left like to think they are Classical Liberals but history tells a different story. And the ideology of the Far Left is unsound. It eventually turns on itself.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 29, 2023
Comment deleted
Peter Smith's avatar

Only after the fact and not on any fundamental grounds since the mystical collectivism of Christianity cannot condemn the mystical collectivism of Nazism, Fascism, Communism and Socialism (all of which are collectivist and therefore far-LEFT ideologies.)

Overall, they all agree on far more than they disagree.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 29, 2023
Comment deleted
Peter Smith's avatar

I would argue that pro-abortion is the individualist and therefore the right-wing position.

Anti-abortion is anti-individual rights, collectivist and therefore a left-wing position.

In short, progressives are more right-wing on abortion than conservatives.

I think these kinds of fundamental confusions are why the conservative movement is where it is and why MAGA happened.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 31, 2023
Comment deleted
Jerry's avatar

This is a classical liberal forum though not "far left".

I don't believe the essay had anything to do with Catholicism...but if that is your lodestar...fair enough.

SV's avatar

It certainly feels like a far left forum sometimes and this piece reads like a religious essay on how not to stray from your one true religion. The facts are clear that Liberals do well at some things and Conservatives do well at others and that for a thriving democracy you need BOTH to function together.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
Mar 30, 2023
Comment deleted