Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Alan Elrod's avatar

Having followed the debate here, I think it needs to be stressed that, while there are some genuinely upsetting anecdotes, there’s no statistical link between trans-inclusive bathroom policies and violence against women. See: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/ncna911106

There is, however, good reason to be concerned about the link between trans-exclusive policies and violence against trans people https://metropolitiques.eu/How-Anti-Trans-Bathroom-Bills-Hurt.html

Expand full comment
Scott M Roney's avatar

This article assumes that only one side of this debate is extremist. Jesse Singal, a science journalist who does detailed investigative work on the evidence for and against youth gender medicine, receives 1000s of messages every year from trans activists telling him he deserves to die and urging him to kill himself. Trans activists have demanded that major media outlets (such as the New York Times) stop all reporting on this controversy. Scientists have refused to publish research findings due to fear of how trans activists will respond. While some on the Right want to eliminate transgender individuals, some on the Left want to eliminate detransitioned individuals. Therefore, contrary to Mr. Elrod's contention, one cannot “debate the scope and limit of trans rights” because such debate is effectively forbidden by those who insist upon an endless scope that is not even limited by the rights of others. Matt Walsh and his ilk are crude opportunists, but their views are made to appear legitimate by the extremism of the transgender movement.

Expand full comment
78 more comments...

No posts