Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joshua Gillelan's avatar

"empowering an authoritarian who trampled over innocents and waged unaccountable violence of its own" -- Sounds like US policy from the 1930s (and episodically before) until . . . NOW, throughout Central America. Viva United Fruit Co.! Viva La Escuela de Americas! Abajo land reform, campesinos, Indios, constitutions, independent judiciary, due process and other civil rights, etc.Of course I mean to express no sympathy for MS-13 or Barrio 18, except that so many of their "associates" had no choice in the matter. The cops and National Guard are as brutal and uncontrollable as the gangs.

Expand full comment
Victor Brongel's avatar

This substack never say nothing about the dictatorship running right now in Brazil, by the liberal president and Supreme Court, also liberal. The brazilian Supreme Court has been destroying democracy in Brazil, by not give the legal process to the charged. And, for example, the judge Alexandre de Moraes (Xandão) is, at same time, the judge, the prosecutor and the victim; all this with the consent of the drunk and corrupt president Luis Inácio Lula da Silva. I now why this substack is silence about this: its because the writers of this substack have a false concept of democracy: to they, democracy is a regime under baton of totalitarian progressive regimes that imposes by force "democracy", silence conservatives, justify that this imposition is a protection of democracy. These celerated was never will talking nothing about El Salvador if, conterfactually, today the old elite of this country, that celebrate "democracy" - like this substack -, would be in the power, "preservating" the "democracy". Because to this substack is more importante the formal democracy rather the actual democracy: if the formal democracy was preservating today in El Salvador, even with the population slave of crime, this substack was clapping the "democracy". I challenging some of the writers of this substack go to El Salvador and talking all this things in the face of a citizen of El Salvador that was enslaved by crime in the past, in the "democracy". Really, people in El Salvador thanks God that one "dictator" is destroying crime, rather preservating "democracy". If it were done from your perspective, population going to suffer with crime. That's why that the perspective of this site, the progressive democracy, is going bankrupt; and just a damned elite believe in this; the population, ostracized and oppressed by this elite - for example, censor conservative ideas against the evil Theory of Gender, labeling conservatives of "fascists". This elite, like Christopher Lasch agues in his book, The Revolt of Elites, its traitor of his people, getting away from them, try to imposes progressives ideas by force - because the liberals and progressives today thinking they are the "lights of civilization" and the conservatives, the people are brutes and rabbles. But, in the end of the day, the people are opressive by this liberal elite - who only think about themselves -: have your convictions desrespected and lost your jobs in a society even more inequal. And, equal El Salvador, the elite of El Salvador have the same think of this substack: they never fought against the crime of the manner that have to combate, because they was a great preocupation with "democracy". But its very easy to an elite preserving "democracy" while they have a great security in theirs fortresses. In the same time, however, the people was devasted by the crime. Nevertheless, if was this the case - the liberal elite preserving "democracy" on top of their fortresses, while the people were ravaged by crime - this substack would be celebrating the vigorous "democracy". Its very ease, in the armchair of the writers of this substack, criticize the El Salvador, without see, in fact, the complexity and suffer of the people of El Salvador.

Expand full comment
13 more comments...

No posts