Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Amine's avatar

Interesting and mostly thoughtful piece — certainly refreshing in this landscape. I am a French Moroccan that has reached an officer rank in the French army and joined an administrative corps. After that moved to North America. One aspect of the piece that I dislike is that religion is conflated with what people call “origins”. Religion is a choice (and many French people with Arab names are not particularly practicing), but in continental Europe your “origins” are inescapable and a frequent topic of conversation, as a source of understanding of who you truly are supposed to be. This is a psychological trap: you can either follow the stereotype attached to you — to make it consistent — or spend a good amount of energy trying to disprove people’s perception of your “origins”. The only way out is to have a more inclusive narrative that defines what it is to be French. For instance in my opinion belief in the importance of gender equality and freedom of speech is a non negotiable precondition to be French. The constitution of the Republic enounciates the universality of mankind — if our nation believed a little bit more in its own founding texts it would be all the better.

Expand full comment
Andras Boros-Kazai's avatar

If Arabs in France make even a small effort to assimilate to their freely chosen new "homeland," they are accepted and recognized as French. Otherwise, not so much.

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts