Discussion about this post

User's avatar
David R. Henderson's avatar

If you're saying that more immigrants will not cause a large loss in the wages of current residents, I agree with you. There's a lot of good evidence on that from economists. I do think, though, that a "living wage" is a bad idea. From what I've read, most people's estimates of the living wage are above $15 an hour. If that were implemented by law, low-skilled workers would have much more trouble finding jobs. Shikha, by the way, is familiar with this argument.

Expand full comment
Pat Barrett's avatar

In reading this summary of Schmitt's core idea, it is clear that the idea as ideology is simply a tool for anyone wishing to usurp power in a classic way: divide and conquer. My grandparents from Italy were villified; my wife and her family were villified as descendents of slaves (her great-grandfather), and my mom's family as Hillbillies from West Virginia. As Joe Scarborough says, once I shake hands with an immigrant who has just taken the oath for citizenship, he's as American as I am. I don't speak Italian nor Hillbilly and my wife is bidialectal in Standard and Black English. Most of my Mexican-American students spoke little Spanish despite our proximity to the border here in Maricopa County. That's America. Some people can't get over it and so the dual ideologies, All people are created equal and some are more equal, have always been with us. It's called bigotry, and all the superficial arguments on economic, pseudo-scientific 'empiricism', religious or other grounds can't disguise it.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts