Discussion about this post

User's avatar
hw's avatar

Thank you for this essay. While I find it unpersuasive in its conclusion, I found it odd in other respects. The author speaks of religion solely in the context of forms of Christianity, and solely as it impacts the political right. What of Muslims or Jews or other religious groups, many of whom identify as liberal Democrats in the US? There is also an implicit blame of liberalism as the reason for the decline of religion, rather than pointing a finger towards the antiquated institutions that refused to adjust to a modern society. Had churches adapted to a broader acceptance of sexuality and identity, for example, the exodus from religious doctrine might not have been so steady. Even were we to accept the author's conclusions, which religious doctrine should prevail in multi-ethnic, pluralistic societies? The author seems to begin with a predetermined conclusion. I would argue that people turned from religion for the same reason they turned from democracy...the institutions became rotted and feeble over time, leadership was reactive to crises, policies shifted dramatically in reaction to whatever crisis damned the last administration. Every benefit you note that is provided by a church is also provided by NGOs, non-profits, community organizations. The reason that people flocked to Trump was that he pretended to be a leader who understood their disillusionment. The reason that the world has rallied around Zekenskyy is that he's actually a leader who stands with his people fighting for a common cause, irrespective of religion. The world doesn't need more religion to function more humanely, it needs better leaders.

Expand full comment
MarkS's avatar

As a 66-year-old man who was raised Catholic, and who became an atheist around age 15 or so (the concept of God just made no sense at all, and still doesn't), I am absolutely on-board with religion being necessary for a stable society.

In my 20s, I married a woman who is a practicing Catholic. I supported her by attending Mass weekly and raising our children in the Church.

Although I am still an atheist as a core belief, the social benefits of religion became clear to me through these decades of practice.

IMO, a revival of tradional religion, lightly but thoughtfully practiced by a majority, is essential if we are not to ultimately undergo societal collapse.

Expand full comment
8 more comments...

No posts